ECT on Australian TV

On Tuesday evening (24 September) the Australian TV programme Insight (Australia’s leading forum for debate and powerful first person stories”) is featuring ECT. The overview says:

“In Australia, the number of ECT treatments has almost doubled in the last ten years, with just under 30,000 sessions taking place in the last financial year.”

I would query that statistic, or at least like to know where it came from. In Victoria (which is home to about one quarter of Australia’s population) there were nearly 19,000 treatments in 2011-12 which would suggest, unless Victoria is using much more ECT than the rest of the country (always a possibility), a total for Australia of rather more than 30,000. And in Victoria the use of ECT has risen from 15,484 treatments in 2003 to nearly 19,000 in 2011-12, a significant increase but well short of the doubling the programme claims.

Unusually the programme has chosen someone with severe memory loss from ECT to speak in praise of the treatment:

“Natalie Deeth can’t remember her wedding. She’s lost 27 years of her memories after undergoing about a hundred electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) treatments for major depression. But Natalie says the memory loss is worth it.”

And also unusually, the psychiatrist promoting ECT, Colleen Loo, is not disagreeing:

“She accepts some people can lose years’ worth of memories from their lives after ECT, but she says those people are at the extreme end of the spectrum.”

Speaking against ECT is psychologist John Read from the University of Liverpool, who is billed as having recently reviewed the literature on ECT and concluded there is “not a single study in 75 years that shows ECT had any lasting benefits beyond the end of treatment, compared to placebo”. More recently, although the programme overview does not mention this, he has together with Roar Fosse published in Frontiers in Psychiatry an article (Electroconvulsive treatment: hypotheses about mechanisms of action) which reviews the literature and concludes that ECT “affects the brain in a similar manner as severe stress or brain trauma”.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in ECT in the media, ECT worldwide. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to ECT on Australian TV

  1. Yas says:

    I am writing a thesis about ECT and I live in Geelong, Victoria. I recently found out that the Geelong Hospital is one of the last practicing institutes of ECT in Victoria. So those numbers for Victoria wouldn’t surprise me as I believe they are doing quite a lot of treatments.

  2. Ian says:

    I am a carer of someone with severe schizoaffective disorder. They have had several extremely serious episodes over 20 years requiring long term hospital admissions (12 to 16 weeks at a time) which proved to be resistant to treatment by any and all drugs.

    In desperation ECT was considered and then used as a last resort. The results were instant! The results were permanent! Yes there is some memory loss but we dont think there is actually that much that is lost – more completely disorganised and extremely difficult to find.

    My partner has had over 100 reatements and when her illness flares up, ECT is now the first coarse of treatment. Dealing with some memory loss is far better than living in the dark bottomless pit of physcosis and depression.

    Our story is documented at http://www.queenslandmentalhealth.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s